PayPal

Givebutter vs PayPal

Compare Givebutter’s all-in-one fundraising platform with PayPal’s donate-button approach, and see how Givebutter allows nonprofits to use PayPal as part of a more complete fundraising system.

We know every nonprofit’s situation is unique, so we’ve compiled all the information you need to compare Givebutter to PayPal and choose the best fundraising platform for your organization. Comparison data last updated in January 2026.

3 reasons nonprofits choose Givebutter over PayPal

Raise more

With Givebutter, you can accept PayPal alongside Apple Pay, Venmo, Cash App, and more—without needing separate accounts.

Pay less

Even with PayPal’s nonprofit discounted rates, you still need to pay for separate marketing tools or CRM software. Givebutter includes those tools for free.

Give better

PayPal helps you accept donations. Givebutter helps you fundraise. With nonprofit-focused support and live guidance, your team gets help with campaigns, donors, and events—not just payments.

Raise more

How do PayPal features stack up against Givebutter?

With PayPal for nonprofits, organizations can accept donations through a trusted payment flow. Givebutter goes further by combining PayPal with a complete suite of fundraising, events, and donor management tools built just for changemakers.

PayPal
Ease of use
Ease of setup
Quality of support
Donation forms
Embeddable forms & donate buttons
Custom branding
Custom donation amounts & labels
Custom fields
Donation dedications
Fund designations
Matching gifts
Giving hub
Fundraising pages
Personalized pages
Public donor messages
Peer-to-peer fundraising
Team fundraising
Leaderboards
Goal bar
Countdown
Fundraising events
Virtual, in-person, & hybrid events
Unlimited ticket types & quantities
Ticket scanning & check-in
In-person payments
Livestream
Live display
Automatic event reminders
Auctions
Mobile bidding
Automated bidding
Bid notifications
QR codes for auction items
Self-service registration & checkout
Auto-charge winners
Payment requests & reminders
Donor management & CRM
Unlimited contacts
Detailed contact profiles
Donor activity tracking & history
Custom donor segments & filters
Self-service importing & migration
Reports & analytics
End-of-year reports
Nonprofit marketing & engagement
Automatic receipts
Outbound email blasts
Merge fields
Custom domains for emails
Peer-to-peer texting
Text-to-donate
Scan-to-donate
Message analytics & ROI
Social sharing
Payment processing
Major debit/credit card donations
Venmo donations
PayPal donations
Apple Pay & Google Pay donations
Donor-advised fund donations
ACH donations
Optional mail a check
Recurring donations
Record offline donations
Import transactions
Automated payouts
Payout reconciliation reports
Support
Live chat support
Email support
Help center
Live workshops & product training
Live fundraising webinars
Price
Platform fee
Payment processor fee
Can donors cover fees?
Users
9.4
9.4
9.5
Offered completely in free plan
Offered completely in free plan
Offered completely in free plan
Offered completely in free plan
Offered completely in free plan
Offered completely in free plan
Offered completely in free plan
$0
Always transparent
Free forever thanks to optional donor tips
0%
2.9% + 30¢
Unlimited
Offered for paid plans only
Offered partially in free plan
Not offered at all
Offered completely in free plan
Offered for paid plans only
Offered partially in free plan
Not offered at all
Offered completely in free plan
Offered for paid plans only
Offered partially in free plan
Not offered at all
Offered completely in free plan
Offered for paid plans only
Offered partially in free plan
Not offered at all
Offered completely in free plan
Offered for paid plans only
Offered partially in free plan
Not offered at all
Offered completely in free plan
Offered for paid plans only
Offered partially in free plan
Not offered at all
Offered completely in free plan
Offered for paid plans only
Offered partially in free plan
Not offered at all
Offered completely in free plan
Pay less

What does PayPal’s pricing model look like?

Discounted PayPal fees apply to approved nonprofits. Changemakers can enroll in PayPal Giving Fund (PPGF) for fee-free donations, but this requires separate enrollment and a different payout process.

With Givebutter, nonprofits can accept PayPal payments directly within their campaigns without incurring platform or processing fees.

PayPal
Price
Platform fee
Payment processor fee
Can donors cover fees?
Users
$0
Fee-free fundraising
Backed by the Givebutter Guarantee
0%
0%
Unlimited
Offered for paid plans only
Offered partially in free plan
Not offered at all
Offered completely in free plan

$0

Additional fees apply for international donations

0%

1.99% + $0.49 (for approved nonprofits)
or
0% via PPGF
(separate enrollment required)

Not listed publicly

How is Givebutter free?

Thanks to optional donor tips, Givebutter’s core fundraising features are free for all nonprofits. When tips are enabled, you pay $0—backed by the Givebutter Guarantee. Prefer to hide tips? Disable them and pay a flat 3% platform fee plus standard processing fees. For more advanced tools,  Givebutter Plus starts at $29/month.

Give better

What do nonprofits say about PayPal support?

PayPal reviews highlight its strength as a payment processor, but it’s not built for nonprofit fundraising. Givebutter offers highly rated support designed for nonprofits, with live chat, email, webinars, and expert guidance for campaigns and donors.

PayPal
Ease of use
Ease of setup
Quality of support
Support
Live chat support
Email support
Help center
Live workshops & product training
Live fundraising webinars
Price
Platform fee
Payment processor fee
Can donors cover fees?
Users
9.2
9.2
9.4
Offered completely in free plan
Offered completely in free plan
$0
Always transparent
Free forever thanks to optional donor tips
0%
2.9% + 30¢
Unlimited
9.0
8.9
8.3
Offered for paid plans only
Offered partially in free plan
Not offered at all
Offered completely in free plan

Hear from real nonprofits what makes Givebutter better

Givebutter makes it ridiculously easy to set up a campaign and start raising funds fast. The design is clean, mobile-friendly, and flexible enough for everything from ticket sales to donations to peer-to-peer fundraising. The ability to accept Venmo, PayPal, cards, and even offline donations in one place? Chef’s kiss.
Michael Ryan W.
Founder, Club Triangle Flint
Methodology

Givebutter’s editorial staff aims to bring you the most transparent and objective comparisons possible. We sourced these comparison metrics directly from fundraising platform websites and third-party review sites like G2, Capterra, and Trustpilot. Score data gathered in January 2026.

PayPal
Already signed up for PayPal?

Switch to Givebutter in minutes, and bring everything with you

Easily import your historical data to Givebutter when you switch—hassle-free and completely self-service. Keep building on your success immediately rather than starting from scratch or waiting for a data transfer.
Transactions
Contacts
Recurring donations
No limits, no costs
Don’t settle for less

Givebutter leads the pack in user satisfaction

We’re proud to say that that we’re the most-reviewed and highest-rated nonprofit software company on G2, the largest independent software review site. Givebutter is ranked as the #1 software for fundraising, donor management, and auctions based on user satisfaction ratings.

Compare Givebutter to popular fundraising sites ->
G2 Grid® Report for Fundraising
Winter 2026

Raise funds better, faster, and for free with Givebutter