Donor appreciation: Find gifts, ideas, & events that inspire

Without thoughtful appreciation, even the most dedicated supporters can lose motivation.

But when donor appreciation is done right—with timely, personalized, and sincere recognition—supporters are more likely to stay involved, give again, and deepen their commitment to your cause. 

We’ve gathered the most impactful donor appreciation examples for every budget and effort level—including thank-you gifts for donors and event ideas to keep supporters engaged and invested for years to come. 

Key takeaways

• Donor appreciation is key to any donor retention strategy. Lack of proper recognition can lead to a drop-off in donor engagement and risk of losing long-term supporters. 
• Repeat donors give 42% more than first-time donors, and retaining donors costs far less than securing new ones.
• Donor appreciation doesn’t have to be complicated or expensive—handwritten notes, social media posts, and personalized thank-you videos can go a long way. 
• Gifts like branded merch, business discounts, or naming rights offer another meaningful way to recognize high-value donors. 
• Take donor appreciation to the next level by hosting a larger event like a gala or networking night. 

The impact of donor recognition & appreciation

Donor retention rates typically hover between 40% and 45%, meaning nearly half of donors never give again—often due to a lack of proper acknowledgement. 

Copied!

Download Started!

‍

When nonprofits commit to sincere, personalized, and consistent recognition, donors remain engaged and committed to the cause. This results in: 

• More donations 💰 Recognized donors feel more connected and inspired to give again—often at higher levels. In fact, repeat donors give 42% more than first-time donors.
• New supporters 🗣️ Satisfied donors become advocates, attracting new supporters to your mission.
• Strong community 👥 Thoughtful recognition—like personalized thank yous or donor spotlights—inspires others to get involved and builds a culture of generosity.
• Saving time and money ⌛ On average, nonprofits spend just $0.20 per dollar raised to retain donors—but acquiring a new donor can cost up to $1.50. 

Start here: Top 5 donor appreciation ideas you can do today

If you’re ready to show your donors their impact but aren’t sure where to start, try these low-lift ideas. Without requiring a lot of time or money, they’re sure to leave your supporters feeling seen and valued. 

1. Personalized thank-you videos 🎥

💛 Best for: Mid-level donors 

Don’t underestimate the power of a heartfelt thank you. Personalized videos strengthen connections and remind donors of the difference they make to your mission. 

💡 Tip: Use Givebutter’s ThankView video integration to send customized thank-you videos to your supporters easily. 

2. Creative social media shout-outs 📣

💛 Best for: Mid-level donors who have contributed to a specific campaign 

Spotlight your donors by tagging them in posts or featuring them in stories. Share the impact of their contributions and include photos or videos of the project they’ve funded when possible. 

💡 Tip: Highlighting the impact of your current supporters inspires others to get involved without making a direct appeal. 

3. Handwritten notes ✉️

💛 Best for: All donors

A handwritten note adds a personal touch that digital messages often lack. Mention specific contributions or milestones to make your message even more meaningful for donors.

Dive deeper

Express gratitude with a free thank-you letter template →

4. Exclusive updates 🤫

💛 Best for: Donors at higher giving levels

Think of exclusive updates as VIP access to your mission. Send behind-the-scenes videos, sneak peeks of upcoming programs, or a donor-only newsletter. 

💡 Tip: Survey donors on what types of updates they’d like to receive. This ensures you deliver content they care about and make them feel heard. 

5. Donor recognition events 🎈

💛 Best for: All donors 

Donor appreciation events don’t have to be extravagant. Even a low-key gathering, like a virtual coffee chat, is an opportunity to connect with supporters, celebrate recent wins, and deepen relationships. 

👀 Stay tuned: We’ll explore more involved event ideas further on if you’re ready to go all out to wow your donors. 

Keep it going: 15 donor gift ideas your supporters will love

Most supporters don’t expect gifts—by sending one, you’ll leave a lasting impression. 

If you’re looking for donor appreciation gifts that are customized, useful, and mission-specific, we’ve got you covered with the 15 ideas below. 

Copied!

Download Started!

1. E-cards 📧

💛 Best for: One-time donors

💰 Cost: $ 

E-cards don’t need to align with a holiday—sometimes, getting a card “just because” can make the strongest impact. 

💡 Tip: Track donor emails in a database for easy access. 

2. Personalized direct mail 💌

💛 Best for: All donors

💰 Cost: $$ 

Take your handwritten note a step further with a donor acknowledgement letter—a more formal message from your nonprofit acknowledging your supporter's contribution. Psst… did you know Givebutter Plus offers discounted direct mail? 

3. Beneficiary thank-you video 📼

💛 Best for: Recurring donors

💰 Cost: $

Sharing impact is an important part of donor communications and helps prevent donor burnout. These videos are especially effective when they highlight specific stories. Ask beneficiaries to share how donations have positively impacted their lives. 

💡 Tip: If possible, include individual supporters' names and donation amounts. 

4. Branded bookmarks or stickers 🔖

💛 Best for: Small donors and new supporters

💰 Cost: $

Show appreciation and get your message into the world without breaking the bank. Stickers or bookmarks featuring your name and logo are both cost-effective options for small donors or new connections. 

💡 Tip: Hand out stickers at large events with your social media handles so donors at all phases of the lifecycle remember you.  

5. Items related to your organization 🐯

💛 Best for: New and recurring donors

💰 Cost: $$

Remind donors why they support you with gifts tailored to your mission. Something small they’ll use or see often, such as a keychain, can keep your nonprofit top of mind.

⚡ Example: If your organization helps people find their voice through creative writing workshops, offer a notebook or poetry zine. 

6. Local business discounts 💰

💛 Best for: Recurring donors

💰 Cost: $$

Collaborate with local businesses to secure discounts for your supporters. This has the twofold effect of showing appreciation and expanding your reach to community organizations and their patrons. 

💡 Tip: If one of your supporters owns a business, consider partnering with them. This fosters a deeper connection as part of your donor cultivation strategy. 

7. Certificates 📜

💛 Best for: Recurring donors

💰 Cost: $

Certificates are a meaningful way to celebrate donor milestones like one, five, or ten years of support.

💡 Tip: Name your certificates strategically to encourage continued support. For example, offer a bronze award for $50 and a silver award for $100. 

8. Branded merch 🧢

💛 Best for: All donors, especially new supporters

💰 Cost: $-$$$

Take your donor thank-you gifts a step further with branded merchandise like t-shirts, caps, water bottles, pens, or tote bags. 

💡 Tip: Keep merch relevant to your mission, and invest a little extra time and effort into the design so your supporters will be excited to use it. 

9. Welcome package 📬

💛 Best for: New supporters

💰 Cost: $$

Create a welcome package for new donors, including a certificate, resources about your organization, and branded merch. Highlight other ways to get involved, like volunteer opportunities and fundraising events. 

10. Gift cards 🎁

💛 Best for: High-ticket donors and significant contributions

💰 Cost: $$-$$$

Recognize your most committed supporters with gift cards. Even small amounts can add up, so it’s best to reserve gift cards for supporters whose contributions deserve a little extra recognition. 

11. Tours

💛 Best for: VIP donors 

💰 Cost: $$-$$$

Offer personalized tours of your facilities or programs to VIP donors. You’ll demonstrate the positive impact they’ve had on your mission and give them an experience to remember.  

12. Educational workshop 👩‍🎓

💛 Best for: Recurring and VIP donors

💰 Cost: $$$

Invite experts in your organization’s field to lead a workshop for donors. Since these supporters are already invested in your cause, they’ll appreciate the opportunity to deepen their knowledge. Provide refreshments and additional resources for your supporters to take home. 

💡 Tip: On a tight budget? Keep costs low with a virtual workshop. 

13. Plaques 🪧

💛 Best for: Large donors

💰 Cost: $$$

Honor major donors with a traditional recognition plaque. Plaques are often used to acknowledge donors who’ve contributed significantly to a specific building, program, or initiative. 

14. Naming decisions 🗣️

💛 Best for: Large donors, corporate donors 

💰 Cost: $

While naming rights don’t cost anything, they hold immense value for the legacy of your nonprofit. Reserve naming rights for major gifts or those who’ve made significant contributions to help sustain your mission long-term. 

15. Original artwork 🎨

💛 Best for: Large donors

💰 Cost: $$$

Original artwork is another meaningful recognition gift for high-ticket donors. Choose pieces that relate to your mission or by artists affiliated with your cause. 

Take it further: 4 donor appreciation event ideas if you want to go big

If you’re ready to go all out, these ideas will help you host an appreciation event to remember. They require a little extra work, but they’ll spread joy, strengthen donor loyalty, and leave supporters feeling deeply appreciated. 

Copied!

Download Started!

1. Networking event 🤝

💛 Best for: Nonprofits targeting professionals

💰 Cost: $$ 

Host a networking event to help your supporters elevate each other’s careers. Reserve a space in a bar or restaurant and provide name tags to make it easier to connect. 

💡 Tip: Add an extra event like a complimentary wine tasting to get people talking. 

2. Impact milestone celebration  📈

💛 Best for: Organizations celebrating a recent achievement

💰 Cost: $$

Host a milestone celebration—like reaching a fundraising goal, launching a new program, or marking a key anniversary for your organization. Include presentations, videos, and other activities to highlight the significance of your achievement and inspire continued support.  

3. Annual donor appreciation gala 💛

💛 Best for: Top donors

💰 Cost: $$$

Treat your top-tier donors to an unforgettable formal celebration with dinner, drinks, and entertainment. Make it an annual event so supporters have something special to look forward to each year. 

💡 Tip: Give your event a name that fits the occasion—like “Gratitude Gala,” “Champions of Change,” or “Mission Makers Dinner.” 

4. Concert 🎶

💛 Best for: Top donors

💰 Cost: $$$

Host a private concert with a local musician for your top supporters. Concerts require more logistics than other appreciation events, but they create memories that leave a lasting impact and reinforce supporters’ connection to your cause. 

How to organize a donor appreciation event in 5 easy steps

Donor appreciation events aren’t just for thanking supporters—they’re also an opportunity to showcase impact, strengthen connections, and enjoy an evening out. 

Follow these five steps for a smooth, successful event that leaves a lasting impression for all the right reasons. 

1. Start with the basics☝️

Lay the groundwork before you dig into the details. Ask yourself: 

• Who 👥 Decide who your event is for. Will you invite all donors or just those who’ve reached a certain giving level? 
• What 🤔 Choose your event format: in-person, virtual, or hybrid.  
• When 📅 Set your date far in advance to accommodate planning, promotion, and travel logistics.
• Where 📍Select your location based on your budget and event type—you could rent a venue or use your own. 
• How 👐 Match your invitations to your event. If you’re hosting an event for all supporters, promote it on social media. If your event is exclusive, mail invitations instead.

2. Set your budget 💸

Build your appreciation event into your nonprofit’s overall budget. From here, decide where you’d like to invest and where you can save. Factor in expenses like venue, food and drinks, entertainment, and invitations. 

 💡 Tip: To stretch your dollars, consider using a board member's home as an event space. Or, host a cocktail hour instead of a dinner. 

3. Create an itinerary ⏰

Keep your event organized and on track by setting your event schedule in advance. While the run-of-show will vary based on the event type, consider including: 

• Welcome address 👋 Kick things off with a warm greeting from your founder or board members. 
• Presentation 🎥 Highlight donor impact with a visual presentation or video. 
• Dinner or drinks 🍽️ Leave time for guests to eat and get to know one another over dinner or drinks. 
• Entertainment 🎉 Add budget-friendly fun—try a photobooth, live music, or lawn games. 

💡 Tip: Build excitement by sending out your itinerary ahead of time. 

4. Assign roles to staff and board members 👯

This is your chance for your board and staff members to give back to your supporters. Assign them to welcome guests, run food and drinks stations, and mingle. 

💡 Tip: Supporters rarely have an opportunity to interact directly with your nonprofit leadership, so be intentional when assigning roles to make things especially fun and memorable. 

5. Thank your donors one last time 💕

End on a strong note by thanking your supporters one last time before they leave. Consider giving a small gift to take home—like a thank-you card, photo, or plant. 

More to explore

Start planning with the ultimate event planning checklist →

Show appreciation with Givebutter 

Donors don’t expect more than a simple thank-you letter—making it even more impactful when you go the extra mile. However you choose to appreciate your supporters, Givebutter has the tools you need to deepen connections and boost retention in one place. 

With a full-flight CRM and nonprofit marketing software, you can filter, segment, and automate outreach—like thank-you notes, direct mail appeal, SMS campaigns, and more—so every donor feels valued and connected to your organization’s mission.

Sign up for your free Givebutter account today to elevate your fundraising strategy, raise more, and build lasting donor relationships. 

FAQs about donor recognition ideas 

What’s the difference between donor appreciation and recognition? 

Donor recognition examples include thank-you notes or newsletters sent after an individual contributes. Donor appreciation takes this a step further with thoughtful gifts, events, or other special communications that highlight how valuable donors are to your organization. 

What is a major donor gift? 

Major gifts are large donations made to your nonprofit. The specific amount varies based on your nonprofit’s size and budget. For established nonprofits, a major gift might be $50K. For smaller organizations, major gifts might be $1.5K. 

What’s the best way to appreciate monthly donors? 

Some of the best ways to appreciate the supporters in your monthly giving program include welcome packs, exclusive updates, local business discounts, or educational workshops. Showing proper recognition for recurring donors is key to any retention strategy. 

How often should you send your donors gifts? 

That depends on the type of gift. Generally, smaller gifts like cards or branded swag are sent a few times a year. Larger gifts like certificates, tours, or milestone celebrations may be offered once a year or less. Remember to balance the gift type and frequency with impact.

What is the best swag for donors?

Your donor swag should be useful, high-quality, and branded with your nonprofit’s logo. Great examples include bookmarks, stickers, water bottles, hats, and tote bags.